Backed by his band Freak Freely, the GRAMMY-nominated star delivered another powerhouse set packed with fan favourites, including The Door, Bad Dreams and Funeral.
Clearly enjoying his return to the coast, Teddy said: “I love you so much, Scarborough. I'm having the time of my life up here!”
It was the US singer’s second concert in consecutive nights at the OAT, after the first one sold out quickly.
Fans were also treated to a performance of Teddy's brand-new single Breakup In Reverse, which was met with a huge reaction from the sold-out crowd.
The evening reached a rousing finale with Teddy's multi-platinum global smash Lose Control, sparking another huge sing-along and bringing his Scarborough double-header to a memorable close.
Showcasing the soulful vocals, infectious energy and emotional connection that have made him one of music's most exciting live performers, Teddy had the Scarborough audience captivated from the very first note.
Opening the show was acclaimed New Zealand-Australian singer, songwriter and multi-instrumentalist Jordan Rakei.
The 2026 season ontinues on Saturday (July 25) with a huge sold-out show from James Taylor.
1. Teddy Swims performs second concert at Scarborough Open Air Theatre
Teddy Swims' drummer showcasing his skills! photo: Cuffe & Taylor Photo: Cuffe & Taylor
2. Teddy Swims performs second concert at Scarborough Open Air Theatre
A packed house for a second night running to see Teddy Swims. photo: Cuffe & Taylor Photo: Cuffe & Taylor
3. Teddy Swims performs second concert at Scarborough Open Air Theatre
US singer Teddy Swims on stage. photo: Cuffe & Taylor Photo: Cuffe & Taylor
4. Teddy Swims performs second concert at Scarborough Open Air Theatre
Fans enjoying the show. photo: Cuffe & Taylor Photo: Cuffe & Taylor