Row over ‘invasive granny annexe’ plans at Whitby property

A row has broken out over plans to build a ‘granny annexe’ in a North Yorkshire garden over concerns about the impact on pedestrian safety.

​Proposals to build a residential annexe for the mother of the owner of a Whitby house have sparked strong objections from neighbours worried about the impact of a proposed ‘parking platform’.

The property, at 9, Westlands Avenue, is located in a residential area of Whitby, less than half a mile from the town centre.

​A neighbour, Adrian Legg, has objected to the plan on the grounds that “any vehicle egressing from the proposed parking platform will have no clear view either to the left or right, and as the adjacent fence is two metres tall, any pedestrians using the footpath will be invisible to the driver and in danger of being struck by the said vehicle.”

9 Westlands Avenue, Garden Looking East.  photo courtesy of applicant.placeholder image
9 Westlands Avenue, Garden Looking East. photo courtesy of applicant.

​He added: “As all specifications for this platform have been omitted from the application, I am estimating that the platform will stand approximately four to five metres above the rear of my property and my garden.

​“This will, in effect, give a person an eye-level view of around six to seven metres down into my property, which has always been secluded and private.

"This will severely invade my privacy.”

​The submitted proposal states that “parking is also provided, accessed from Station Road, and this will be a steel-framed structure with a path linking it to the dwelling.

​“In addition to the above, the scheme will provide two parking spaces, accessed from Station Road.

"This is in excess of what is normally required for a one or two-bedroom annexe.”

​However, the local highway authority said it was not opposed to the scheme, subject to the implementation of several conditions and noted that the applicant had “revised the location of the access to avoid the close proximity of the metal railings outside the adjacent plot”.

​Officers said that any gates or barriers “must not be able to swing over the existing highway, provision to prevent surface water from the site/plot discharging onto the existing highway must be constructed, and the wooden racecourse style fence will need to have a section removed”.

​Another objector, Ian Laurence, said: “Safety will be reduced for pedestrians and motorists on a very narrow road with the addition of the parking and drop kerb.

​“The pavement on Station Avenue where the proposed parking would be on the east side, has no drop kerbs currently and is used exclusively by pedestrians.”

​Whitby Civic Society also objected “on the grounds of over-development of the site, noting the understandable concerns raised by neighbours about the loss of amenity in the area which would result if the application were approved.”

​North Yorkshire Council has not set a date for deciding on the plans, which are currently open to representations from members of the public.

​

News you can trust since 1882
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice