Scarborough Councillors welcome progress in South Bay water investigation amid warning of ‘no easy answers’

Councillors have welcomed ‘progress’ in a South Bay water quality investigation but have warned there is ‘no simple answer’.

Coastal councillors have said they are pleased with the progress of a “detailed investigation” into the cause of pollution in the South Bay following a water quality summit held yesterday (Thursday, June 5).

Scarborough's South Bayplaceholder image
Scarborough's South Bay

Yorkshire Water’s chief executive Nicola Shaw has also said the company will invest around £180m in reducing sewage leaks from storm overflows.

However, speaking at a meeting of the Scarborough and Whitby area constituency committee, Coun Liz Colling said it was unlikely that there would be a “simple answer to this question”.

Scarborough And Whitby Acc Meeting. 07.06.24. Courtesy Anttoni Numminen/LDRSplaceholder image
Scarborough And Whitby Acc Meeting. 07.06.24. Courtesy Anttoni Numminen/LDRS

Scarborough’s South Bay has been blighted by a ‘poor’ rating for bathing water quality from the Environment Agency.

Local businesses have warned that failure to address the situation speedily could impact visitor numbers and the local economy.

Concerns have also been raised that the coastal pollution is not just limited to the South Bay.

Coun Eric Broadbent told the committee: “There are reports that the North Bay is turning and some of the samples are getting worse and worse, year-on-year.”

“I think the North Bay should also be watched very, very closely,” he added

Coun Janet Jefferson said she thought bringing together different organisations for the water quality summit was “excellent” and said that “progress has been made”.

However, Coun Rich Maw said he “absolutely welcomed” the further scrutiny but was “disappointed that the Surfers Against Sewage action group was not invited” to Thursday’s event.

Councillors vowed to hold a further meeting to which groups such as Surfers Against Sewage could be invited to contribute.

But committee members said they needed more time to consider the format of such an event after concerns were raised that a public meeting might be “hijacked”.

Coun Heather Phillips said that because bathing water quality is an “emotive issue” the meeting “could become something that could be hijacked quite easily by specific interest groups”.

She added that “we all need to be comfortable with who we are talking to”.

The Scarborough and Whitby area constituency committee agreed that public transparency was important and that there would be “further discussion” on how to proceed.

Meanwhile, the Environment Agency has said that with funding from partners, it will carry out “much more detailed investigative work at Scarborough South Bay” this summer using a number of different microbiological techniques.

News you can trust since 1882
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice