Cayton must have fancied their chances of claiming victory when they dismissed the Clarence Drive club for 161, only Aaron Howard, 32, and Jamie Gilbank, 25, impressing for the hosts.
Aussie Nick Strangio struck 39 in reply and Paul Pennock added 36, but the three-pronged attack of Ryan Baldry, 4-28, Ben Briggs, 3-17, and Nathan Robson, 3-38, saw Cayton all out for 125.
Staxton are now level on points with Cayton after an impressive eight-wicket win against Flixton 2nds.
The basement team posted a decent 193-6, Will Hutchinson leading the way with 37, while Geoff Hill, 28, Mark Shackley, 27no and Mick Walmsley, 27, all made good starts.
Jodie Robson’s powerful 75 and 60 from David Morris put Staxton in the driving seat, Nick Gibson’s unbeaten 38 wrapping up the win.
Staithes edged to a two-wicket win at Nawton Grange despite a great all-round show from Nick Thornicroft.
The former Yorkshire player struck 29 and Mike Wearmouth 27 not out as Grange were all out for 135, Stuart Theaker bagging 4-20.
Thornicroft then snapped up 5-29 to give Staithes a few nervy moments before they scraped home thanks to 35 from Rich Ward and 26 not out from Ian Dixon.
Heslerton eased to a six-wicket win at home to struggling Forge Valley.
Spinner Daniel Jeminson took 4-29 as Valley were restricted to 122-9, Alex Glass, 31, and John Flinton, 25, the only batsmen to shine.
Jake Keyworth, 53, and Sam Triffitt, 43no, ensured the win for Heslerton.
Adrian Turnbull’s unbeaten 119 guided Ebberston to a 126-run win at second-from-bottom Scalby.
Eddie Craggs also smashed a decent 59 as the visitors posted 240-2, and Ian Atkinson snapped up 5-37 as Scalby slipped to 114 all out in reply despite a defiant 38 from Joe Hills.
Mulgrave secured promotion from Division A with a 117-run win at Wykeham.
M Spagnuolo, 40, and Chris Clarkson, 37, shone as the leaders were dismissed for 160, Matthew Graves taking 3-3 and Dave Pearson 3-28 for the hosts.
Pete Shepherdson hit 23 in reply but was offered little assistance as the home side slumped to 43 all out, Craig Thompson bagging 4-18.
Seamer still look odds-on favourites to join Mulgrave in the top flight after their 14-run home win against Wold Newton.
Fine knocks from Gary Lawton, 41no, Darrol Lewis, 37, Jon Broadhead, 27, and Gregg Chadwick, 25, helped Seamer post 181-8, Andy Moore taking 4-40 and J Knaggs 3-17.
Lawton capped a fine all-round day with 3-12 as Newton were dismissed for 77, Paul Greenhough taking 4-13.
Openers Craig Sanderson, 96no, and Lee Jack, 26no, steered Sherburn to a 10-wicket win at Grindale.
Daley Wharton took 4-24 as Grindale were dismissed for 131.
Cayton 2nds won by 91 runs at home to Cloughton thanks to an unbeaten 87 from Brian Heywood, allied with 50 from Darren Walker and 41 from S Williams as they racked up 222-5. Cloughton managed 131-5 in reply.
Settrington defeated visiting Brompton by 161 runs.
The hosts made 237-9, Steve Beal hitting 47, A Morley 46 and Jonty Rounthwaite Jnr 38, James Bruce claiming 5-74.
Andy Monkman’s 4-14 then sent Brompton crashing to 76 all out.
Division B leaders Staxton 2nds lost at home to Scalby 2nds to give their rivals for the title a huge boost.
Matty Pearson hitt 44 and Kingsley Gray 33 as the hosts were all out for 153, Tony Geall, Tim Barton and Adie Hollingsworth scooping identical figures of 3-33 for Scalby.
Joe Ledden’s 71 then made sute of the Scalby win.
Second-placed Thornton Dale won by three wickets in a high-scoring contest at Fylingdales.
The hosts posted 211-5, Barry Heyes smacking 71 not out and Roy Grove 70, while Steve Husband added 35.
Lyle King’s 77 guided Dale home despite 4-74 from Harry Purves.
Ravenscar are still in the mix thanks to a swift seven-wicket win at home to Sewerby 2nds, who were relegated by the result.
Jon Murrell, promoted from the second team, proved to be the match-winner for the hosts with 5-2 while Will Warwick bagged 3-25 and skipper Jish Rewcroft struck an unbeaten 29 to seal the win.
Bradley Milburn’s excellent 120 helped relegated Scarborough 3rds to a 114-run win at Forge Valley 2nds.
Ben Rowe took 4-44 as Valley were skittled for 109 in pursuit of Scarborough’s 223-7.
Ebberston 2nds won by six wickets at home to Wykeham 2nds to edge closer to the Division C title.
Mike Horsley bagged 5-27 as the viusitors were dismissed for 123, Ian Thompson leading the way with 44 while Ben Norman was undefeated with 24.
Will Tyson, 35, and Jason Oakley, 27no, wrapped up the win for Ebberston.
Flamborough moved into second thanks to a nine-wicket win at Muston.
Harry Burton took 4-12 as the hosts were all out for 96, Steve Pratt hitting 29 and D Meer 28.
Andy Dixon, 40, and Luke Dixon, 30no, sealed the win.
Ryedale romped to a massive 181-run win at home to Heslerton 2nds.
Sam Batty struck a cracking 71 while Neil Cowton added a fine 65, Dan Hardy making 48 and Owen Cowton 29no in Ryedale’s massive 303-4.
Hardy then took 3-7 as Heslerton were all out for 122, despite 25 from John Howden.
READERS SCARBOROUGH BECKETT CRICKET LEAGUE RESULTS SATURDAY AUGUST 8 *denotes home team
*Filey 161 all out (A Howard 32, J Gilbank 25) beat Cayton 135 all out (N Strangio 39, P Pennock 36, R Baldry 4-28, B Briggs 3-17, N Robson 3-38) by 26 runs. Pts 18:7
Staxton 195-2 (J Robson 75, D Morris 60, N Gibson 38no), beat *Flixton II 193-6 (W Hutchinson 37, G Hill 28, M Shackley 27no, M Walmsley 27) by 8 wkts. Pts 17:5
*Heslerton 125-4 (J Keyworth 53, S Triffitt 43no) beat Forge Valley 122-9 (A Glass 31, J Flinton 25, D Jeminson 4-29) by 6 wkts. Pts 16:3
Staithes 136-8 (R Ward 35, I Dixon 26no, N Thornicroft 5-29) beat *Nawton Grange 135 all out (N Thornicroft 29, M Wearmouth 27no, S Theaker 4-20) by 2 wkts. Pts 17:6
Ebberston 240-2 (A Turnbull 119no, E Craggs 59) beat *Scalby 114 all out (J Hills 38, I Atkinson 5-37) by 126 runs. Pts 20:2
*Cayton II 222-5 (B Heywood 87no, D Walker 50, S Williams 41) beat Cloughton 131-5 by 91 runs. Pts 17:4
Sherburn 136-0 (C Sanderson 96no, L Jack 26no) beat *Grindale 131 all out (G Cousins 37, S Ward 32, D Wharton 4-24) by 10 wkts. Pts 17:2
*Seamer 181-8 (G Lawton 41no, D Lewis 37, J Broadhead 27, G Chadwick 25, A Moore 4-40, J Knaggs 3-17) beat Wold Newton 77 all out (W Gray 27, P Greenhough 4-13, G Lawton 3-12) by 104 runs. Pts 19:4
*Settrington 237-9 (S Beal 47, A Morley 46,J Rounthwaite jnr 38, J Bruce 5-74) beat Brompton 76 all out (A Monkman 4-14) by 161 runs. Pts 20:4
Mulgrave 160 all out (M Spagnuolo 40, C Clarkson 37, M Graves 3-3, D Pearson 3-28) beat *Wykeham 43 all out (P Shepherdson 23, C Thompson 4-18) by 117 runs. Pts 18:5
Scarborough III 223-7 (B Milburn 120, D Foster 43) beat *Forge Valley II 109 all out (N Cook 35, B Rowe 4-44) by 114 runs. Pts 20:4
Thornton Dale 212-7 (L King 77, M Clark 30no, H Purves 4-74) beat *Fylingdales 211-5 (B Heyes 71no, R Grove 70, S Husband 35) by 3 wkts. Pts 17:8
*Ganton beat Bridlington II – Match Conceded by Bridlington II Pts 20:-10
*Ravenscar 66-3 (J Rewcroft 29no) beat Sewerby II 65 all out (J Murrell 5-2, W Warwick 3-25) by 7 wkts. Pts 19:1
Scalby II 156-4 (J Ledden 71) beat *Staxton II 153 all out (M Pearson 44, K Gray 33, T Geall 3-33, A Hollingsworth 3-33, T Barton 3-33) by 6 wkts. Pts 18:5
Seamer II beat *Cloughton II – Match conceded by Cloughton II Pts 20:-10
*Ebberston II 127-4 (W Tyson 35, J Oakley 27no) beat Wykeham II 123 all out (I Thompson 44, B Norman 24no, M Horsley 5-27) by 6 wkts. Pts 17:3
Flamborough 97-1 (A Dixon 40, L Dixon 30no) beat *Muston 96 all out (S Pratt 29, D Meer 28, H Burton 4-12) by 9 wkts. Pts 20:0
*Ryedale 303-4 (S Batty 71, N Cowton 65, D Hardy 48, O Cowton 29no) beat Heslerton II 122 all out (J Howden 25, D Hardy 3-7) by 181 runs. Pts 20:3