Brid Town survive late Garforth comeback to earn FA Trophy penalty shoot-out win

Bridlington Town progressed to the next round of the FA Trophy after surviving a late Garforth Town comeback and holding their nerve in a tense penalty shootout following a 2-2 Friday night draw.

Bridlington got off to the perfect start thanks to a moment of magic from set-piece distance. A push on Billy Marshall earned Bridlington a free-kick right on the edge of the box, and Ben Tweed stepped up to curl a stunning right-footed effort directly into the top-left corner to give Bridlington an early 1-0 lead.

Tom Allan scores the winning penalty for Bridlington Town in the shoot out at Garforth in the FA Trophy.   Photo by EC Mediaplaceholder image
Tom Allan scores the winning penalty for Bridlington Town in the shoot out at Garforth in the FA Trophy. Photo by EC Media

Bridlington managed the tempo for much of the opening period before Garforth gradually built momentum and took control of the last 10 minutes or so of the half.

In the 43rd minute, Garforth thought they had equalised, but the assistant referee’s flag went straight up for offside.

Charlie Birdsall, Ben Tweed and Ahmed Salam celebrating Salam's penalty at Garforth in the FA Trophy.    Photo by EC Mediaplaceholder image
Charlie Birdsall, Ben Tweed and Ahmed Salam celebrating Salam's penalty at Garforth in the FA Trophy. Photo by EC Media

Garforth came out quickly in the second half, and in the 48th minute, a dangerous corner dropped dead into a crowded box. After a bit of a goalmouth scramble, the ball was poked into the back of the net to level the game.

Bridlington came back strong after the equaliser and nearly restored their lead in the 50th minute.

The ball broke through to Toby Marriott down the wing, who drove deep and cut the ball back into the penalty area, but the ball was played just behind the supporting runs.

Garforth threatened in the 52nd minute with a curling strike toward the top-right corner, but Tom Allan produced a vital defensive play by deflecting the header wide.

Ben Tweed's free-kick beats the Garforth keeper in Friday's FA Trophy clash. Photo by EC Mediaplaceholder image
Ben Tweed's free-kick beats the Garforth keeper in Friday's FA Trophy clash. Photo by EC Media

Bridlington stepped up their attack in the 59th minute as Luca Bolino drove into the box, beat his marker, and saw his low shot blocked out for a corner.

The resulting corner flew past everyone, but Ahmed Salam recovered the loose ball on the wing and laid it back to Bolino, who attempted to whip a cross back into the danger zone, but the cross struck the arm of the Garforth man attempting to block the cross. A moment of thought by the referee and he pointed to the spot.

Salam stepped up coolly converted the penalty to make it 2-1 to Bridlington.

Garforth pushed hard for a way back and finally broke through in the 85th minute. A long throw-in into the penalty area was not dealt with by the Bridlington defence, and the sides were locked in again 2-2.

The handball by Garforth Town which saw Brid Town awarded their penalty. Photo by EC Mediaplaceholder image
The handball by Garforth Town which saw Brid Town awarded their penalty. Photo by EC Media

With no further goals before the final whistle, the tie went straight to a penalty shootout, where Bridlington held their composure to secure safe passage into the second qualifying round, winning 5-4 on penalties after six attempts each.

News you can trust since 1882
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice